Kaitlyn

Winner of the all-female third season of NXT, Kaitlyn parlayed that breakout into a WWE Divas Championship reign in January 2013, holding the title for 153 days before losing it to AJ Lee at WWE Payback. A powerhouse built on a background in competitive bodybuilding, her spear was her calling card throughout a four-year WWE run defined by hard-hitting physicality and a memorable rivalry with Lee. She returned briefly from 2018 to 2019, appearing in WWE’s Mae Young Classic tournament and making a few independent wrestling appearances.

Over half a decade removed from her last match, Bonin believes she’s in better form than ever before to make an in-ring return. With AJ Lee back in the WWE fold, Kaitlyn has publicly stated she has “unfinished business” with her former rival. There were rumors she would appear at the 2026 Royal Rumble in Saudi Arabia, but it never came to fruition. For now, she remains unsigned and ringside-ready, watching the door.